Hi I’m Clint Smith, this is Crash Course Black American History and today we’re
talking about the Great Migration. You know sometimes, moving is exciting.
Maybe an exciting job opportunity pulls you to a brand new city and so you get to move someplace
you've never been. Or you go from being a college student to a working adult and get to move into
the apartment of your dreams… or if you were like me, one that you shared with seven other people.
Shout out to your early twenties. But sometimes, people don’t leave a
place simply because they want to, but because, in one way or another, they’ve been pushed away.
In what would become known as The Great Migration which took place in the early to mid-twentieth
century, many Black Americans who lived in the South, moved to the northern United States,
to the urban South, and to the West. They did this to find better jobs, more economic mobility,
and to escape the ever-present threat of violence in the South.
Let's start the show. INTRO
I want to note up top that this episode will address some challenging topics
like extreme violence. During the Great Migration large
numbers of Black Americans left the Jim Crow South in two waves, one from around 1910 through 1940,
and another from 1940 to 1970. It was one of the largest domestic migrations in American history.
You see, in 1910 most Black Americans lived in the South - 90% in fact. And this makes
a lot of sense because most of slavery had been centered in the South.
And even after the emancipation of enslaved Black Americans,
many folks stayed in the same areas where they had previously lived.
But by 1940 around 1.5 million Black Americans had left their homes, and that percentage of Black
Americans in the South had dropped to 77%. And by 1970, that number would drop to 52%.
They mostly went to cities like Chicago, Illinois, Detroit, Michigan, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania,
and New York City. In my own family, we had a lot of people leave New Orleans,
and actually move out to the West Coast, settling in and around Los Angeles.
In the early 1900s, Black Americans were being both pushed out of the South,
and also pulled toward the North. As for why they were pushed away from the South: after slavery,
many Black Americans were subjected to a physically taxing and economically
precarious system called sharecropping. To learn more about how unfair this system was,
let's go to the Thought Bubble. So let's say there’s a farmer, we’ll
call him Farmer Joe. Maybe Farmer Joe, or his dad or granddad before him, had a plantation where he
had enslaved workers who tended to the land. After the war was over, because of the 13th amendment,
Farmer Joe could no longer enslave those workers, so he had to find a different arrangement in order
to plant and harvest the crops on that land. This arrangement was known as sharecropping.
The way it worked was like this: Farmer Joe brought in some help.
They might be formerly enslaved people, or the descendents of formerly enslaved people,
or poor whites. He provided these workers with land, cabins, seeds, animals, and the tools
needed to work on the farm from the beginning of the season through harvest time. All of these
things were provided to the workers on credit. By the end of the harvest season, Farmer Joe had
a certain expectation of how many crops he would receive, and if that expectation wasn’t met,
he could claim that the workers were now even further indebted to him than they were before.
And because of high interest rates, unpredictable harvest seasons, and deceptive agreements by the
landowners, many sharecroppers found themselves in a cycle of endless debt
that was difficult, if not impossible, to escape. There were even laws in place that prevented
sharecroppers from leaving the land if they were in debt to the landowner, and Farmer Joe
could even send his workers to jail for these debts - which would go on to shape the racialized
prison industrial complex. Thanks, Thought Bubble.
Even when Black Americans owned their land, factors like unpredictable weather and pests
like the boll weevil made farming less and less sustainable and also less profitable.
Because so many Black Americans in the South were earning next to nothing because of this cyclical
debt, the idea of finding more stable work in the north became increasingly appealing.
Stories from those who had made their way to these other cities trickled back down South.
Jobs in the north, the story went, created by the auto industry, meatpacking industry,
and steel & iron industry, were paying Black people a lot more money.
Black men that were earning only $0.75 a day while working in the South
could make up to $5 a day working in the North. And for many, it seemed too good to pass up.
Another huge reason for the Great Migration was the impact of Jim Crow and domestic terrorism
by groups like the Ku Klux Klan. Even though the Reconstruction Amendments promised
Black Americans freedom from slavery, the right to vote (for men at least), and full citizenship
with all of the benefits it was supposed to carry, many White Americans weren’t okay with that. They
showed their displeasure with both institutional and interpersonal violence, filling the lives of
Black Southerners with misery and terror. To start, the Southern States used Jim Crow
laws to segregate Black communities and prevent them from having access to any
of the resources that would make their homes, neighborhoods, and communities better. As a result
many Black communities were dilapidated, and generally just in poor, terrible condition.
What’s more, as we’ve talked about before, Black people couldn’t even use the same water fountains,
hospitals, waiting rooms, and even cemeteries as white people. I mean, you would think racism
would at least rest with the dead, but it followed you even after you were buried.
Many of these Southern states used literacy tests, poll taxes, and property requirements to make sure
that Black Americans couldn’t vote - eroding the power of the 14th and 15th Amendments.
And then they took it to the extreme, by violently destroying Black communities - think
the Wilmington, North Carolina Riots of 1898 and the Atlanta Riots of 1906.
There were groups whose main goal was to maintain White supremacy and Black subordination in
the South, used to beat, harass, and lynch Black people with unsettling frequency.
Other White people who were not necessarily affiliated with these groups also both watched and
participated in these violent acts. In fact, many people used to attend lynchings as family events.
This violence prompted Black people to literally run for their lives to the North and the West.
Some have argued that, because of this, we should actually think of the Great Migration
as a sort of refugee crisis. In her award-winning book The Warmth of Other Suns, the Pulitzer-prize
winning journalist Isabel Wilkerson writes: “They traveled deep into far-flung regions
of their own country and in some cases clear across the continent. Thus the Great Migration
had more in common with the vast movements of refugees from famine, war, and genocide in other
parts of the world, where oppressed people, whether fleeing twenty-first-century Darfur
or nineteenth-century Ireland, go great distances, journey across rivers, deserts, and oceans or
as far as it takes to reach safety with the hope that life will be better wherever they land.”
Newspapers like the Chicago Defender and other informal networks like church groups, benevolent
societies, and Black Pullman Porters told the stories of many Black Americans who were thriving
in the North, and that encouraged many Black Southerners to take the risk and come join them.
But once they arrived there, things weren’t just magically better. Oftentimes, things
remained really tough. Poverty was wide-spread and segregation was still in place. Racism, while it
may have looked different in these urban cities, wasn’t just limited to the South. So Black folks
established benevolent societies through churches and other organizations to help the new migrants
and their families adjust to life in the North. Another fascinating part of the story of the Great
Migration is that many white people in the South, as more and more Black people began to leave,
actually got nervous and were worried that too many Black people were leaving.
See, as terribly as Black people were treated on a social and political level,
the economic infrastructure of the South relied heavily on Black people’s labor.
Some employers increased their wages to stem the tide, but most of the time that wasn’t enough.
White southerners got so desperate that they tried to pressure newspapers into telling more
negative stories about Black life in the North, they would block trains and buses filled with
migrants from leaving the South, and even beat and intimidated people for attempting to leave.
I mean, think about, you were beaten if you stayed, and beaten if you tried to leave.
That was Black life in a nutshell. Something to remember is that, no matter what,
it is never easy to leave home. Though much of the land Black people lived on in the early 20th
century carried a lot of pain, it also carried a lot of memories. It was part of their lineage.
It was part of their history. Leaving home isn’t easy, but that
also shows you how desperate people were for both economic opportunity and for safety.
And while it wasn’t perfect, for many, the North and the West did provide that. People
were able to get economic opportunities that they otherwise wouldn’t have had.
And while, to be sure, violence against Black folks did exist in the North, it wasn’t nearly as
extensive as it was below the Mason Dixon line. What’s more the Great Migration created huge hubs
of Black urban spaces and culture. It would go on to give us some of our best artists,
musicians, and writers. The Great Migration
was nuanced, complicated, and dynamic, and the story we tell about it should reflect
that complexity. It’s not just a story of what was done to Black people, but it serves as an example
of Black Americans taking control of their lives, identities, and destinies,
in a country that was constantly attempting to strip all of those things away from them.
The writer Isbael Wilkerson puts it best: “Over the decades,
perhaps the wrong questions have been asked about the Great Migration. Perhaps it is not a question
of whether the migrants brought good or ill to the cities they fled to or were pushed or pulled
to their destinations, but a question of how they summoned the courage to leave in the first place
or how they found the will to press beyond the forces against them and the faith in a country
that had rejected them for so long. By their actions, they did not dream the American Dream,
they willed it into being by a definition of their own choosing. They did not ask to be
accepted but declared themselves the Americans that perhaps few others recognized but that
they had always been deep within their hearts.” Thanks for watching. I’ll see you next time!
Crash Course is made with the help of all these nice people
and our animation team is Thought Cafe. Crash Course is possible with the help
of all the people who bought the 2021 Crash Course Learner Coin, and by all our Patrons
on Patreon. Thank you to all of our patrons and supporters for making Crash Course possible.